Hello dear
Welcome To Erie Island Coffee Co.
Erie Island Coffee Co., located in Elyria, Ohio, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for coffee lovers and food enthusiasts alike. This charming café is known for its friendly staff and accommodating service, setting the tone for a pleasant morning experience. Customers rave about the selection, including the signature EIC coffee and delightful breakfasts like the Hammy Sandwich and blueberry bagels. Although they source food from US Food Distributors, patrons appreciate the quality and freshness of items like pastries and muffins. The inviting picnic area outside adds to the café's charm, making Erie Island Coffee Co. a beloved spot within the community.
About
Erie Island Coffee Co.
Welcome to Erie Island Coffee Co., a quaint gem nestled in the heart of Elyria, Ohio. Located at 148 Middle Ave, this inviting café is your go-to spot for a delightful coffee experience paired with comforting food options. With a phone call away at +1 440-412-4060, you can inquire about their menu or simply drop by for a warm welcome and an aromatic brew.
Erie Island Coffee Co. is not just renowned for its exceptional coffee varieties but also for its friendly atmosphere. Patrons like LéJhon can't help but rave about the kindness of the staff, especially during those early mornings. Their recommendation? The perfect pairing of the EIC on a blueberry bagel, a nod to the café's ability to cater to special requests.
Each cup of coffee tells a story of quality. Reviewers such as Allan Robison highlight the rich flavors, reminding us that although the café sources its food from US Food Distributors, the taste—like their cheese pastry and muffins—is still commendable. The heart of Erie Island Coffee Co. resonates with good vibes and quality choices.
As you delve further into the menu, dishes like the Hammy Sandwich burst with flavor, featuring simple yet delightful ingredients like buttered bread, egg, ham, and cheese. Letts C described the satisfaction of enjoying a meal outdoors at a picnic table, further emphasizing the charming and well-maintained ambiance of the area.
For those with a sweet tooth, the dark chocolate mocha with caramel, as noted by Katrina Fox, offers one of the best experiences in town—rich, cold, and immensely satisfying. Whether you stop in for breakfast or lunch, you will leave with a smile, thanks to freshly made selections and an accommodating staff.
In a world where coffee shops can become mundane, Erie Island Coffee Co. stands out as a cozy retreat with exceptional offerings. From the lattes to the bagels, every visit feels like a treat. Mariana Hren summarizes it perfectly—“everything is made fresh, the staff is sweet,” resulting in a leisurely coffee experience that’s worth the wait. Here, every sip is harmonious, and every bite nourishes both the body and soul. So, stop by Erie Island Coffee Co. soon and experience this delightful oasis for yourself!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I recommend the EIC on a blueberry bagel ! Everyone is always friendly and very accommodating to special requests. Really appreciate how kind they are early in the morning ”
“ Cute little shop. I stopped in for a coffee and got a dark chocolate mocha with caramel, iced. One of the best I've had. They serve breakfast and lunch. ”
“ This cafe is small, but cute and wonderful. I ordered the Hammy Sandwich, a plain bagel, a Nitro Reese's coffee, and a pack of their signature blend coffee. The sandwich was simple (buttered bread, egg, ham, and cheese.), yet delicious. The nitro had a standard coffee taste, with hints of chocolate and peanut butter, after breaking through a thick and creamy layer of foam on top. It was nice to be able to sit in the town center at a picnic table to eat, the area is clean and well maintained. ”
“ The coffee is good. The food is all supplied by US Food Distributors. For the quality of the coffee, you would think they could find some local bakeries to partner with. However, with that said, the cheese pastry and the muffin were good and flavorful. I continue to go to this coffee shop. It is the best in Elyria. ”
“ This place is a gem!! So glad we waited the extra 1/2 hour, until the place opened at 730 am, to continue our road trip in the morning. The barista was friendly and fast, and the locals knew her The cook was friendly and is fantastic at what he does! The design of the place was super cute and original as well Onto the flavors: We both ordered a SOB (South of the Border) wrap, but on gluten free bread, which was toasted to perfection... It. Was. Delish!!!! Highly recommend! Did not have much kick, but could definitely taste the jalapeños in it. Since it isnt a premix that they cook with, it could be customized to dietary needs, which is AMAZING! Had a black coffee, house blend. So good! Also, a sugar free, brown sugar cinnamon iced latte with almond milk. It had a reminiscent taste of a cinnamon roll. ”
“ This little cafe is so cute, the cook is amazing and makes the E.I.C’s to die for, everything is made fresh, the bagels are perfect and not hard to eat. The staff is sweet, sometimes there is only one worker and the wait can be long but it’s worth it. The lattes are very good!! ”
“ When I visit my son and his family in Elyria, I always get my coffee and breakfast from this location. This local coffee shop is a hidden gem and easily one of the best spots in town. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warmth, professionalism, and genuine hospitality. The staff go above and beyond to make every visit feel personal, and their attention to detail is unmatched. The food is exceptional—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick breakfast or settling in for lunch, everything on the menu is consistently well-prepared and delicious. The atmosphere is equally impressive: clean, cozy, and thoughtfully designed. It’s the kind of place where you can catch up with friends, knock out some work, or just relax with a good cup of coffee. It’s clear the owners take pride in creating a welcoming space for the community. I highly recommend supporting this business—you won’t be disappointed. ”
“ This is the best coffee spot around. I drive from Amherst because the coffee and food is that good. They have a ton of flavors to choose from. The food is fresh, flavorful and always perfect. The service is always incredible and everyone is always nice. The avocado toast is my favorite thing to eat and my favorite coffee is the pistachio ice cream latte. You really can’t go wrong with anything though. ”